This is one tough year to be putting on the swami hat and dusting off the crystal ball. There are so many moving pieces affecting the group health/individual/Medicare/ Medicaid world that it will be hard enough to analyze what happened after the fact, much less before.
Enough with the dissembling. Here goes.
1. Consolidation will accelerate. After a hiatus due to the still-slushy credit markets, big health plans will start acquiring second tier ones. Expect this to happen after mid-year, for reasons due not only to the credit markets but also to goings-on on Capitol Hill. Among the health plans likely to get attention are Humana, MVP Health Plan, AmeriHealth, and Priority Health.
1.a. Coventry will also be on the list; it has solid penetration in a number of second-tier and tertiary markets along with a strong workers comp managed care business. The company has been hamstrung by operating issues; if these appear to be under control it will likely be in play in 2009. Check their talk at the JP Morgan conference later this week for an early indication of progress. (Note I own shares in Coventry)
2. Health plans will split in their reaction to legislation pending in DC. Some will wail and whine, while others will look for the opportunities. Among those already reasonably well positioned are Aetna and UHG (particularly their AmeriChoice unit). Count on AHIP to bemoan the unfairness of it all, and ask for subsidies in the form of risk pools and governmental coverage of high cost claims.
3. Expect more scrutiny of healthplans serving Medicaid and Medicare populations, as the Feds are ramping up their efforts to crack down on abusive and fraudulent practices. The new Administration will want to send a message to health plans that an expansion of S-CHIP and other governmental programs is not a license to steal. There will likely be more Wellcares hitting the headlines in 2009.
4. Health plans will begin to focus more effort on being easy to work with – especially for providers. Increasing frustration with the administrative burden placed on them by health plans is causing providers to become more selective about participation; the health plans that are ‘low-maintenance’ will have better relations with more providers, and the ones on the other end of the spectrum will not. See the Verden Group’s reports for a heads-up on how health plans stack up in the eyes of providers.
5. The Medicaid population will grow substantially, as well the percentage enrolled in some variation of a managed care plan (currently above 60%). Health plans active in this market will do well – if they are priced right.
6. The economic stimulus plan is critical for health plans. Enrollment depends on jobs; with unemployment at a sixteen-year high at 7.2% and smaller employers dropping coverage as they attempt to stay afloat, expect enrollment to continue to drop thru mid-year. This will hit the big commercial plans hardest, although a few are somewhat insulated as the drop in commercial will be offset by growth in Medicaid.
7. Don’t expect much growth in the individual plans; they are unaffordable for many and restrictions on pre-ex make them unattractive for others. Until and unless the pre-ex and medical underwriting issues are resolved, growth will be slow – at best.
Check back in twelve months.
Jan
12
Increasing frustration with the administrative burden placed on them by health plans is causing providers to become more selective about participation; the health plans that are’low-maintenance’ will have better relations with more providers, and the ones on the other end of the spectrum will not. See the Verden Group’s reports for a heads-up on how health plans stack up in the eyes of providers.