Transparency. The basic requirements of consumer-directed health plans (CDHPs) are price transparency and outcomes data. The foundational concept underlying CDHPs is that consumers will ask how much services cost, and providers will be able to tell them.
Oh were it only possible. It looks like the six million folks who have bought CDHPs from an insurance industry eager to tout them as the second coming of (pick a deity) are having a tough time getting the pricing info they need to make informed decisions.
Aetna is ahead of the rest of the industryin providing information about phyeicians and pricing; they have been providing actual reimburement amounts for specific procedures in selected markets for some months. Humana is also doing this on a limited basis in at least one market (southern Wisconsin).
Here’s a quote from the Chicago Tribune article:
” But basic data about what services cost generally aren’t available. Medical providers and insurers consider this to be highly sensitive competitive information, and their contracts require that it remain secret.
That leaves consumers with more financial responsibility for their care but without the tools to manage these expenses.
“The market just isn’t ready yet to deliver on the promise of these new insurance products,” said Larry Boress, president of the Midwest Business Group on Health…”
While recent legislation will require hospitals and some other facilities to disclose their prices, the “prices” will be the list prices, and not the discounted rates. Thus this requirement may not be terribly helpful for consumers looking for useful information.
What does this mean for you?
Another (very large) hiccup on the way to consumer-driven nirvana.
Thanks to FierceHealthcare for the tipoff to the Trib’s article.
Insight, analysis & opinion from Joe Paduda